Published Mailchimp Benchmark Public media nonprofit

How South Florida's public media station earned a 632% return on SMS spend during a fundraising drive.

WLRN, the PBS and NPR affiliate for South Florida, had reached the ceiling of what email alone could raise. Adding text messages to its email appeals, on one Mailchimp platform, raised an extra $34,450 in a single fall drive.

Brand
WLRN
Market
Miami, Florida
Objective
More donations during fundraising drives
Two radio hosts with headphones talking into microphones in a bright broadcast studio

Published benchmark outcomes.

The extra donations compare the fall 2025 campaign with SMS added against email alone; the click-through rate is compared with the average Mailchimp customer.

  • 632%return on SMS spend
  • $34Kmore in donations from adding SMS
  • 47%higher SMS click-through rate than the average Mailchimp SMS user

Fall 2025 fundraising drive. The station credited more than $100,000 of its $1 million fall drive to Mailchimp. First-party lifecycle benchmark published by Intuit Mailchimp.

The growth constraint.

WLRN never charges for its journalism, so it depends on underwriting and two major fundraising drives a year. As traditional funding tightened and audiences moved to social and streaming, those drives had to work harder.

By 2024, email had hit a ceiling: open rates were flat and donations had plateaued. Email also lacked the urgency a live drive needs. The station’s previous email platform did not offer text messaging at the time, and outside SMS vendors were slow, expensive and hard to connect.

  1. Merge the listsEmail and SMS subscribers become one audience.
  2. Segment the donorsHigh-value donors targeted, recent donors left out.
  3. Send email and text togetherEach appeal reaches supporters in both channels.
  4. Test and refineSubject lines, SMS formats and images tested for clicks.

Campaign mechanism.

SMS marketing · Email · Segmentation · Embedded forms · A/B testing

One audience, two channels
The station merged its email and SMS lists into one audience and planned every message in one place, using Mailchimp SMS alongside email.
The right ask for each supporter
Segments targeted high-value donors and automatically left out people who had just given, so the extra messages during a drive did not wear out loyal supporters.
More sign-ups
Embedded forms on the station’s pages brought in more contacts to reach during the next drive.
Testing what works
A/B tests tuned subject lines and SMS formats. Text messages with an image drove more clicks than those without.

Why the mechanism worked.

Strategic takeaways from the WLRN benchmark and the economics behind the result.

Text creates urgency
A drive has a deadline. A text is read within minutes, which is exactly what a time-bound appeal needs and what email struggles to deliver.
SMS added to email, not instead of it
The gain was measured against email alone. Supporters who ignored one channel answered the other, so the two together raised more than either would.
Respecting donors keeps them giving
Suppressing recent donors meant more messages did not mean more annoyance. Relevance protects the list for the next drive.
Pay as you go
Buying the minimum SMS credits each month and topping up during drives kept costs in line with the station’s uneven sending.

Deploying this playbook for your business.

You do not need an enterprise media budget to capture the same economics. Here is how Overtop Media Digital Marketing puts this play to work inside our mailchimp email marketing.

Plan the drive as a sequence
Announcement, reminders, matching-gift moments and a final push, across email and text, with dates set before the drive starts.
Segment donors by value
Major donors, monthly givers, lapsed donors and new subscribers each get their own message and frequency.
Grow the list between drives
Forms, landing pages and Meta lead ads build the audience you will need for the next campaign.
Report in dollars raised
Every message is tied to donations, so you know what each channel and each send was worth.
OVERTOP Specialist Execution

How OVERTOP applies this growth architecture.

Overtop Media Digital Marketing is a Charlotte agency in Mailchimp’s partner program. When our specialists deploy SMS marketing and Email inside Mailchimp email marketing, we engineer every campaign inside the OVERTOP Partner Infrastructure and the OVERTOP Performance Stack, built to surpass Google’s performance benchmarks and best practices.

Closed-loop CRM and revenue signals

Inside the OVERTOP Partner Infrastructure, we connect call recordings, booked consultations and closed-deal values through closed-loop analytics and attribution back into Mailchimp, so automated bidding optimizes for qualified pipeline and margin rather than raw form fills.

Charlotte and national audience sculpting

Our senior strategists pair first-party customer lists and intent signals with negative-audience governance across Charlotte and the Carolinas as well as multi-state national markets, concentrating budget on decision-makers ready to buy.

100/100 landing-page speed

Paid media compounds when clicks land without delay. Every destination we build on the OVERTOP Performance Stack renders instantly with verified 100/100 mobile and desktop PageSpeed Insights scores, turning ad spend into booked revenue.

Explore our mailchimp email marketing architecture or request a growth plan from OVERTOP tailored to your market and revenue goals.

Where this playbook fits best.

You do not have to be a public media nonprofit to capture the same advantage. We deploy this architecture for:

  • Nonprofits and public media
  • Churches and faith organizations
  • Schools and alumni associations
  • Membership organizations
  • Event and festival organizers
  • Any business with time-limited offers

We engineer growth systems like this for arts and cultural organizations, and across every industry we serve.

Ready to put Mailchimp behind your pipeline?

Tell us about your business, your market and your revenue targets. Our specialists will map how Mailchimp fits your growth plan.

Explore OVERTOP mailchimp email marketing

More Mailchimp growth playbooks.

View all Mailchimp growth playbooks

Published Mailchimp Benchmark

Published Intuit Mailchimp benchmark: WLRN case study (February 2026). Official source library: Intuit Mailchimp Case Studies. Playbook analysis by Victor Bubuioc, MBA, Digital Performance and Growth Expert at Overtop Media Digital Marketing, published October 10, 2026.