Published Pinterest Ads Benchmark Department store retailer

How JCPenney earned 116% higher return on ad spend with Pinterest Top of Search ads.

During the 2025 holidays, JCPenney put its products in the first slots shoppers see when they search Pinterest for fashion and gift ideas. Against its usual campaigns, the ads drew more than two times the click-through rate and a far higher return.

Brand
JCPenney
Market
United States
Objective
Reach holiday shoppers at the moment they search
Red, white and brown paper shopping bags filled with tissue paper and holiday gift tags

Published benchmark outcomes.

Compared with JCPenney’s business-as-usual Consideration campaigns on Pinterest.

  • 116%higher return on ad spend
  • More than 2Xhigher click-through rate

Pinterest’s own data, comparing Top of Search ads campaigns with business-as-usual Consideration campaigns, United States, November 2025, 7-day click attribution window.

The growth constraint.

For a department store, the buying decision often happens before a shopper ever reaches a product page. People search, scroll and form opinions in real time, and the store that shows up first while they are looking has the best chance of the sale.

For the 2025 holiday season, JCPenney wanted to test more ways to reach high-intent shoppers who were actively searching for fashion and gift inspiration. The goal was simple: get its products in front of the right people at the exact moment they were ready to discover something new.

Pinterest example of shoppable product Pins for sunglasses with a Shop button

Campaign mechanism.

Top of Search ads · Catalog sales campaigns · Holiday season timing

The top search slots
Top of Search ads placed JCPenney products in the search gallery and in the top ten slots of search results and Related Pins, where browsing turns into buying.
Run from the product catalog
The ads ran through the Catalog sales objective, so they drew straight from JCPenney’s product feed, the same system behind shopping on Pinterest.
Timed for the holidays
Pinterest’s own global data from May 2025 shows 45% of clicks happen within the top ten search results. Owning those slots in the busiest season put JCPenney at the front of the line.
Compared with the usual
Results were measured against the brand’s regular Consideration campaigns, one of the standard Pinterest ad campaign types, so the gain shows what the placement itself was worth.

Why the mechanism worked.

Strategic takeaways from the JCPenney benchmark and the economics behind the result.

A search is a signal
Someone typing “gifts for her” or “holiday party outfit” has told you what they want. Ads that answer the search feel like results, not interruptions.
Products, not just pictures
Catalog ads show the actual item with its details, so the click comes from someone who already likes what they see.
First place gets the click
With so many clicks going to the top ten results, being there matters more than being anywhere else on the page.
Holidays reward the prepared
The feed, the budget and the placements were ready before the peak, so the campaign could capture demand the moment it arrived.

Deploying this playbook for your business.

You do not need an enterprise media budget to capture the same economics. Here is how Overtop Media Digital Marketing puts this play to work inside our pinterest ads management.

Get your feed in shape
Clear titles, sharp images, correct prices and stock. A clean catalog is what lets your products appear in shopping placements at all.
Own the searches that sell
We find the searches your buyers use on Pinterest and make sure your products show up at the top for them.
Plan peak season early
We set up and test well before the holidays, so the account is learning and ready when shoppers arrive. Our ecommerce marketing plans start there.
Cover the same search on Google
Shoppers compare across platforms. Our Google Ads management and Pinterest ads management run as one plan.
OVERTOP Specialist Execution

How OVERTOP applies this growth architecture.

Overtop Media Digital Marketing is a Pinterest Business Partner in Charlotte. When our specialists deploy Top of Search ads and Catalog sales campaigns inside Pinterest Ads Management, we engineer every campaign inside the OVERTOP Partner Infrastructure and the OVERTOP Performance Stack, built to surpass Google’s performance benchmarks and best practices.

Closed-loop CRM and revenue signals

Inside the OVERTOP Partner Infrastructure, we connect call recordings, booked consultations and closed-deal values through closed-loop analytics and attribution back into Pinterest Ads, so automated bidding optimizes for qualified pipeline and margin rather than raw form fills.

Charlotte and national audience sculpting

Our senior strategists pair first-party customer lists and intent signals with negative-audience governance across Charlotte and the Carolinas as well as multi-state national markets, concentrating budget on decision-makers ready to buy.

100/100 landing-page speed

Paid media compounds when clicks land without delay. Every destination we build on the OVERTOP Performance Stack renders instantly with verified 100/100 mobile and desktop PageSpeed Insights scores, turning ad spend into booked revenue.

Explore our pinterest ads management architecture or request a growth plan from OVERTOP tailored to your market and revenue goals.

Where this playbook fits best.

You do not have to be a department store retailer to capture the same advantage. We deploy this architecture for:

  • Retailers with an online catalog
  • Department and specialty stores
  • Gift, jewelry and accessory sellers
  • Home goods and furniture stores
  • Toy and hobby shops
  • Any business with a busy season

We engineer growth systems like this for retail and e-commerce, and across every industry we serve.

Ready to put Pinterest ads behind your pipeline?

Tell us about your business, your market and your revenue targets. Our specialists will map how Pinterest ads fits your growth plan.

Explore OVERTOP pinterest ads management

More Pinterest ads growth playbooks.

View all Pinterest Ads growth playbooks

Published Pinterest Ads Benchmark

Published Pinterest benchmark: JCPenney case study. Official source library: Pinterest Business Success Stories. Playbook analysis by Victor Bubuioc, MBA, Digital Performance and Growth Expert at Overtop Media Digital Marketing, published October 10, 2026.