Published Mailchimp Benchmark Fitness accessories e-commerce brand

How a fitness accessories brand earned 142x ROI on its first SMS campaign by putting email and text in one place.

Gymwrap ran email on Mailchimp and SMS somewhere else, so it could not see which customers preferred which channel. Moving text messages onto Mailchimp, tested head to head with the old provider, settled the question.

Brand
Gymwrap
Market
California, United States
Objective
Prove SMS adds revenue on top of email
Woman in workout clothes tying back her hair in a gym before training

Published benchmark outcomes.

Revenue per recipient was $0.587 on Mailchimp SMS against $0.119 with the previous provider, using identical creative.

  • 142xROI on its first full SMS campaign
  • 5xhigher revenue per message than its previous SMS provider
  • 30%of total attributed revenue from Mailchimp

Head-to-head test from Black Friday through Cyber Monday; both lists were people who had shown interest in the brand. First-party lifecycle benchmark published by Intuit Mailchimp.

The growth constraint.

Gymwrap makes headbands that stay put during workouts. Its year is decided in January, February and March, when New Year’s resolutions drive the biggest sales, and a lean team manages more than 139,000 subscribers.

Email lived on Mailchimp and SMS lived with another provider. With the data split, the team could not tell whether a customer who ignored email would answer a text, or whether SMS was adding revenue or just splitting it with email.

  1. Run a fair testSame creative, two SMS providers, Black Friday to Cyber Monday.
  2. ConsolidateEmail and SMS on one platform with Shopify data.
  3. Rebuild the flowsCart, welcome and re-engagement on live store data.
  4. Reach the right channelEmail for some customers, text for others.

Campaign mechanism.

SMS marketing · Email · Shopify integration · Automation flows

A fair test first
From Black Friday through Cyber Monday, identical creative ran through Mailchimp SMS and the existing provider, to see which one actually earned more.
Email and SMS together
After the test, SMS moved to Mailchimp, connected with email and the Shopify integration for one view of every customer.
Flows on live store data
Abandoned cart, welcome and re-engagement flows were rebuilt to run on real-time Shopify data.
Customers reached where they respond
Instead of archiving people who stopped opening emails, the team could see who preferred text and reach them there.

Why the mechanism worked.

Strategic takeaways from the Gymwrap benchmark and the economics behind the result.

Test before you switch
Running the same creative through both providers at the same time proved the difference came from the platform, not the offer.
One view of the customer
With email, SMS and store data together, an inactive email subscriber became an active SMS buyer instead of a lost customer.
Automation runs at peak season
Flows kept selling during the busiest three months without adding campaign work for a small team.
Fewer tools, less waste
Consolidating removed $100 a month in duplicate fees, and more importantly gave the team one source of truth.

Deploying this playbook for your business.

You do not need an enterprise media budget to capture the same economics. Here is how Overtop Media Digital Marketing puts this play to work inside our mailchimp email marketing.

Prove incrementality
We test SMS against email-only before scaling it, so you know text is adding revenue, not moving it around.
Plan your peak season
Whether your rush is January or December, the flows, offers and send calendar are ready weeks ahead.
Respect the channel
Text is personal. We keep SMS for moments that matter, with clear consent and easy opt-out.
Fill the top of the funnel
Meta ads and Google Shopping ads bring new shoppers in; email and SMS turn them into repeat buyers.
OVERTOP Specialist Execution

How OVERTOP applies this growth architecture.

Overtop Media Digital Marketing is a Charlotte agency in Mailchimp’s partner program. When our specialists deploy SMS marketing and Email inside Mailchimp email marketing, we engineer every campaign inside the OVERTOP Partner Infrastructure and the OVERTOP Performance Stack, built to surpass Google’s performance benchmarks and best practices.

Closed-loop CRM and revenue signals

Inside the OVERTOP Partner Infrastructure, we connect call recordings, booked consultations and closed-deal values through closed-loop analytics and attribution back into Mailchimp, so automated bidding optimizes for qualified pipeline and margin rather than raw form fills.

Charlotte and national audience sculpting

Our senior strategists pair first-party customer lists and intent signals with negative-audience governance across Charlotte and the Carolinas as well as multi-state national markets, concentrating budget on decision-makers ready to buy.

100/100 landing-page speed

Paid media compounds when clicks land without delay. Every destination we build on the OVERTOP Performance Stack renders instantly with verified 100/100 mobile and desktop PageSpeed Insights scores, turning ad spend into booked revenue.

Explore our mailchimp email marketing architecture or request a growth plan from OVERTOP tailored to your market and revenue goals.

Where this playbook fits best.

You do not have to be a fitness accessories e-commerce brand to capture the same advantage. We deploy this architecture for:

  • Online stores on Shopify
  • Fitness and apparel brands
  • Brands with a strong peak season
  • Businesses using a separate SMS tool
  • Celebrity and creator-led brands
  • Any store with repeat purchases

We engineer growth systems like this for sporting goods and outdoor gear, and across every industry we serve.

Ready to put Mailchimp behind your pipeline?

Tell us about your business, your market and your revenue targets. Our specialists will map how Mailchimp fits your growth plan.

Explore OVERTOP mailchimp email marketing

More Mailchimp growth playbooks.

View all Mailchimp growth playbooks

Published Mailchimp Benchmark

Published Intuit Mailchimp benchmark: Gymwrap case study (March 2026). Official source library: Intuit Mailchimp Case Studies. Playbook analysis by Victor Bubuioc, MBA, Digital Performance and Growth Expert at Overtop Media Digital Marketing, published October 10, 2026.